Under 19/ Colts Best and Fairest (Peter Taylor Medallist from 2009)
| Player |
Year |
| Bradley Keegan |
2011 |
| Warwick Johnson |
2010 |
| Alex Bresner |
2009 |
| Anthony Brown |
2008 |
| Todd Patterson |
2007 |
| Joel Krushka |
2006 |
| Jarrod Price |
2005 |
| Jarrod Price |
2004 |
| Jarrod Price |
2003 |
| Sam Page |
2002 |
| Jacob Norris |
2001 |
| Jarrod Fletcher |
2000 |
| Danny Hall |
1999 |
| Warwick Fenner |
1998 |
| David Wickham |
1997 |
| Michael Peters |
1996 |
| Mark Statton |
1995 |
| Jon Alexander |
1994 |
| Glen Cream |
1993 |
| Andrew Gower |
1992 |
| Vaughan Radford |
1991 |
| Brent Colegrave |
1990 |
| Michael Jones |
1989 |
| Troy Roberts |
1988 |
| Johnathon Bye |
1987 |
| Wayne Couch |
1986 |
